Related Formula
Δ Q = BEproducts - BEreactants$$\Delta Q = BE_{\text{products}} - BE_{\text{reactants}}$$
Core Logic
Reaction 1 releases energy (+20 MeV$+20 \text{ MeV}$), meaning the product is more stable:
BEHe⁴ - BEHe³ = 20 MeV (1)$$BE_{He^{4}} - BE_{He^{3}} = 20 \text{ MeV} \quad \dots (1)$$
Reaction 2 absorbs energy (-0.9 MeV$-0.9 \text{ MeV}$), meaning the product has less total binding energy change but is relatively close:
BEHe⁵ - BEHe⁴ = -0.9 MeV (2)$$BE_{He^{5}} - BE_{He^{4}} = -0.9 \text{ MeV} \quad \dots (2)$$
Step 1: Compare Stabilities
From (1): BEHe⁴$BE_{He^{4}}$ is significantly larger than BEHe³$BE_{He^{3}}$.
From (2): BEHe⁵ = BEHe⁴ - 0.9 MeV$BE_{He^{5}} = BE_{He^{4}} - 0.9 \text{ MeV}$, which implies BEHe⁵$BE_{He^{5}}$ is slightly less than BEHe⁴$BE_{He^{4}}$.
Thus, BEHe⁴ > BEHe⁵ > BEHe³$BE_{He^{4}} > BE_{He^{5}} > BE_{He^{3}}$.
The stability directly corresponds to the total binding energy here (and BE per nucleon leads to a similar ranking given small mass differences), so:
X₄ > X₅ > X₃$X_4 > X_5 > X_3$
Pattern Recognition
Positive Q-value means the products are structurally tighter (more stable). Negative Q-value means you lost stability. Simply tracking algebraic differences gives the hierarchical ranking.
Chapter Mix
Class 12 Physics: Nuclei